The Other Bees

The Other Bees header image
As honey bees decline, researchers examine the role of native pollinators.

It’s a warm August day, and I am traveling with OSU entomologist Sujaya
Rao on country roads west of Salem, through a hilly mosaic of Christmas tree
farms, vineyards, and hayfields. We pull over at a field carpeted with purple
blooms of red clover.

The air vibrates. Circling over the field are hundreds of fat, fuzzy bumble
bees. Looking like Goodyear blimps of the insect world, the large native bees
fly from flower to flower. The pollen sacs on their hind legs grow heavier
by the minute. It takes some work to spot the smaller honey bees in the crowd,
despite the fact that there are several tiers of rented honey bee hive boxes
stacked in the field.

“With all those commercial honey bee hives sitting out there, don’t
you think you’d see more honey bees out here?” asks Rao. “We
are learning that it is not necessarily true.”

This red clover field is planted for its seed. Oregon is the world’s
largest producer of red clover seed and a major producer of several other clover
varieties that are planted around the globe as animal forage and soil-enriching
cover crops. Western Oregon’s climate is perfect for producing premium
clover seed, which can be grown with minimal irrigation and then dried in the

honey bee photo by Lynn Ketchum.

Imported from Europe hundreds of years ago, the honey bee is not the only purveyor of pollen. Photo: Lynn Ketchum

Good pollination is key to excellent clover seed production. Both domestic
honey bees and native bumble bees gather pollen out of the dense heads of clover
flowers, each flower head made up of as many as 200 tiny tubular blossoms.
Each tubular blossom, when pollinated, produces one red clover seed. The more
blossoms visited, the more seed set. Rao and William Stephen, a bee expert
and OSU professor emeritus of entomology, have a grant from the grower-funded
Oregon Clover Commission to investigate the relative roles that honey bees
and native bees play in pollinating clover seed crops. They want to know what
kind of flowers each kind of bee visits and how far each will travel to get
pollen and nectar.

hover fly photo by Lynn Ketchum.

This hover fly, hovering over a hydrangea blossom, joins bumble bees, moths, hummingbirds, and other native pollinators to provide an essential service for life on earth. Photo: Lynn Ketchum

Honey bees are the workhorses of most agricultural pollination. Docile enough
to be handled, European honey bees were domesticated thousands of years ago
and later brought to the New World. Extremely sensitive to their environment,
honey bee populations have declined significantly over the past few decades.
Like modern livestock, most honey bees are consigned to living in crowded quarters
where, without careful management, they are prone to diseases and parasites
that knock them back periodically.

The latest honey bee crisis, known as “colony collapse disorder,” has
been front-page news during the past year. In some regions of the country,
but not Oregon, many of the honey bees and their wild colonies have disappeared.
Though no single cause has been pinpointed, a recent study in Science has
identified a possible factor, a virus. Honey bee populations in the Pacific
Northwest are not seriously affected by the disorder at this time, according
to Michael Burgett, an OSU professor emeritus of entomology. But Oregon biologists,
conservationists, and growers are increasingly concerned about the overall
decline of pollinators, and they are looking at native pollinators as a kind
of ecological insurance policy for pollination of crops and native plants.

“A lot of attention has been spent on honey bee pollination,” says
Rao, who is an associate professor in OSU’s Department of Crop and Soil
Science. “But we don’t really know how much pollen is transferred
by other types of pollinating insects such as bumble bees and leaf cutting

bee in clover field photo by Lynn Ketchum.

Bumble bees live individually in holes or natural cavities for a single season. They may specialize in collecting nectar from just a few plants during their short lives. Photo: Lynn Ketchum

Native pollinators fly under most people’s radar. But bumble bees, carpenter
bees, and sweat bees are among the 4,000 kinds of bees native to North America.
A study published in the April 2006 issue of the journal Bioscience reported
that native insects pollinate $3 billion per year in crops in the United States.

Sometimes called the “forgotten pollinators,” native bees have
life cycles quite different from domesticated honey bees, explained Stephen.
Native bees do not live together in huge colonies as honey bees do. They don’t
have to make vast quantities of honey, because they live for only one season.
They live alone or in small groups in holes or natural cavities. Honey bees
are long-lived generalists, able to pollinate many kinds of plants; native
bees are often specialized and focus on a few kinds of plants during their
short lifetimes.

Rao in exclosure photo by Lynn Ketchum.

OSU entomologist Sujaya Rao checks a series of exclosures where she can exclude all but one kind of bee to compare the activity of each type of pollinator. Photo: Lynn Ketchum

Rao walks out into the red clover field and deftly traps individual bees for
examination, each in its own tiny bottle. Their hind legs are laden with oblong
pollen sacs, some dusty yellow or saffron orange; others are shiny and brown
and look like earwax.

Each kind of flower has pollen of a slightly different color,” explains
Rao. “I record the time and place I collect each bee, then later, under
a microscope, I determine what kinds of pollen each kind of bee collects at
particular times of day. That way, we can see if the honey bees are truly loyal
to the crop they were ‘hired’ to pollinate.”

Driving over a ridge, we visit another field. This one is covered in white
and purple heads of arrowleaf clover, another commercial seed crop. We pull
up to a glass jar topped with a blue plastic-finned lid hanging from a pole.
The jar is full of bees. “Just look at all these native bees,” Rao
exclaims. “I just put this out this morning. There must be more than
100 in here. This blue color is irresistible to them.”

man with bee beard photo by Lynn Ketchum.

OSU Extension forester Brad Withrow-Robinson sports a “bee beard,” demonstrating the social aspect of domesticated honey bees, a characteristic that more solitary bumble bees do not share. Photo: Lynn Ketchum

The jar is warm and vibrating in my hand; I see no honey bees inside. But
like a fatal attraction, bumble bees, sweat bees, and orchard bees flock to
Rao’s blue traps, allowing her to see which species are there at any
given time through the bloom season. This affinity for a single hue prompted
Rao and Stephen to see whether the color blue can be used to attract additional
native pollinators to a flowering field.

A long clothesline festooned with blue plastic flags hangs along the edge
of another of the clover seed fields. Rao paces slowly away from the line,
with pen and paper in hand. For two minutes, she tallies every bee she sees—both
honey bees and bumble bees—at different distances from the blue line.

At another stop, we visit a series of room-size mesh-covered cages along the
edge of a blooming red clover field. In each cage, Rao and Stephen have put
only one kind of bee—honey bees or bumble bees or smaller, shiny leaf
cutting bees. “Control” cages have no bees in them at all. When
the bloom is finished, they will measure the seed yield in each cage and compare
the productivity of each pollinating species.

Other people are paying increased attention to native pollinators as well. “We
are concerned that overreliance on honey bees as crop pollinators is putting
all of our eggs in one basket,” said Joe Williams from U.S. Department
of Agriculture’s Natural Resources Conservation Service in Corvallis.
Williams and the nonprofit Xerces Society are trying to determine which plants
are most attractive to native pollinators through the seasons, so they can
recommend plants for growers to sow near their fields. They are encouraging
landowners to plant native flowering plants near crop fields to provide a place
for native bees to nest and give growers a back-up for pollination.

What’s good for native bees is good for commercial beekeepers and their
honey bees, said Corvallis beekeeper and OSU-trained ecologist Karen Finley. “Any
time a grower is attentive to native pollinators, honey bees will benefit as
well,” said Finley. Honey bees use native plants and wild habitat too,
especially after crops have finished blooming. And native bees add to the insurance
that both crops and wild plants will be pollinated and set fruit.


Rao with blue flags. Photo: Lynn Ketchum

A few years ago, OSU entomologist Sujaya Rao (below) made an important discovery.

"I had set out jars designed to trap Asian lady beetles," recalled
Rao. "I set out jar traps with lids of all colors—red, yellow, green,
blue. When I came back the next day to collect my beetles, I noticed that the
jars with the blue lids had bumble bees in them—sometimes hundreds of
bumble bees, as well as other native bees. I was in a fallow barley field,
with no flowers to attract any bees. I was expecting beetles, but there were
the bees."

Rao contacted Bill Stephen, a retired OSU entomologist and a world expert
on native and solitary bees. They began conducting experiments, using different
colored jar lids, in different parts of the state. In every region, the native
bees always preferred blue over any other color.

Rao with tarp. Photo: Lynn Ketchum

"We soon realized that the blue lid has magic in it," said Stephen. "No
other bee of any kind is known to be attracted to something purely on the basis
of color."

Discovering the mystery of the color blue was a scientific gold mine. "We
had no reliable method for taking a census of native pollinators," Stephen
recalled. "Until now."

The entomologists are experimenting with blue flags arrayed across a crop
field (right) to see whether growers can use them to attract native bees into
their fields.

Published in: Food Systems, Ecosystems